Connect with us

Latest News

FCC says it is not bound by Supreme Court rulings

Published

on

The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) is not bound by the decisions of the Supreme Court but can ask for direction from its judgements, the court declared, defining the legal position of judicial precedents and prescribing tight conditions for filing review petitions.

The Federal Constitutional Court has said in its opinion that Supreme Court judgements are solely of persuasive value for the FCC. The constitutional court, however, may follow a legal precedent set by the Supreme Court, if it is in accordance with law and Constitution.

The court also made it very clear that the scope of review authority is quite narrow and only extends to particular circumstances.

The court held that a review petition might be entertained only if there was an error apparent on the record or an omission which causes a miscarriage of justice. Review petition is not a device to re-argue a case or to get a fresh hearing of the matter.

The court said that in review procedures it does not retry the whole case, but looks to see if there is an obvious error in the record of the initial case.

The FCC also cautioned against routine filing of review petitions, advising litigants and counsel to approach the court for review only when there exist genuine and legally valid grounds.

It cautioned that frivolous or malicious review petitions could entail fees of Rs25,000 or more.

It also said that an Advocate-on-Record who files frivolous or malicious review petitions could also be subjected to disciplinary punishment.

The Advocate-on-Record or the party involved shall be obliged to file a certificate prior to filing a review petition indicating the reasons on why review is sought.

The court further directed to deposit Rs50,000 as security for hearing of a review petition.

In the event of dismissal of a review petition or its declaration frivolous or malicious, the deposited security may be lost, says the Federal Constitutional Court.

The ruling further said review petitions could be handled through distribution without an oral hearing in certain instances.

FCC Clarifies Scope of Right to Appeal

The Federal Constitutional Court also defined the procedure for appeals against decisions of High Courts under Article 199 of the Constitution.

It said that permission from the FCC was necessary under Article 175F(1)(c) prior to initiating an appeal against a High Court judgement issued under Article 199.

The court emphasised that leave to appeal is not an appeal as of right. An application becomes an appeal only once leave has been granted by the court.

It further clarified that the dismissal of a leave-to-appeal motion does not mean that the High Court’s decision has been affirmed.

The court said it did not have to give extensive grounds when refusing an application for leave to appeal.

It noted that a non-speaking ruling or an order without specific rationale does not per se be a foundation for filing review petition.

When the court is at the leave-to-appeal stage it looks at whether there is a legal question worthy of examination or whether intervention is required to prevent a miscarriage of justice.

FCC rejects Balochistan Trading Company’s review petition

The Federal Constitutional Court dismissed a review appeal submitted by Balochistan Trading Company and directed for forfeiture of the security deposited by the company in the meanwhile.

The court found that the firm had not identified any error obvious on the face of the record that would warrant a review of the earlier decision.

The court noticed that the review petition was reiterative of the arguments advanced in the proceedings.

Therefore, the company’s petition for the restoration of its lease and possession was dismissed.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

First selection list for MBBS admissions in Punjab’s government medical colleges released

Published

on

By

The first cut list for admission to MBBS in government medical colleges of Punjab has been announced and the minimum cut-off for vacant merit seats is 93.297 per cent.

University of Health Sciences (UHS) officials said King Edward Medical University, Lahore, recorded the highest final score of 95.3697 per cent, while Rasool University Medical College Mandi Bahauddin recorded the lowest score of 93.297 per cent.

The spokesperson said that a total of 3,796 open-merit seats have been allocated across 19 government medical colleges in the province.

MDCAT 2026 concludes across Pakistan with 138,158 candidates registered

According to the UHS spokesperson, Maryam Nawaz Sharif Medical College, Mianwali, established this year, recorded a minimum closing merit of 93.3121 per cent. Rasul University Medical College, Mandi Bahauddin, had the lowest closing merit at 93.297 per cent.

The UHS has also released selection lists for various reserved-seat categories, including overseas candidates. Successful applicants must submit the application fee by November 21, a spokesperson said.

Candidates can download the fee form from the admission portal and pay the fee online. Selected candidates will also be required to submit original academic documents to their assigned medical college to complete the admission and admission process.

Continue Reading

Latest News

Punjab steps up Madrasa registration drive, issues certificates to 19 religious seminaries

Published

on

By

Registration of religious seminaries is underway with the Punjab Endowment Board under the Home Department of Punjab and special registration counters have been set up to manage the seminaries and facilitate the registration process.

The registration process will be done through the Punjab Charity Commission’s online portal, ensuring a quick and easy process. Through a simplified and transparent mechanism, seminaries will be registered within seven days of submitting their application.

All seminaries registered with the Directorate General of Religious Education or registered under the Societies Registration Law are eligible to complete registration with the Commission. Registration will make it easier for seminaries to comply with legal and administrative requirements regarding charitable activities, as well as matters related to bank accounts.

Punjab government guarantees autonomy to seminary leaders, resolves registration and bank account issues

Once registered with the Punjab Charity Commission, religious seminaries can easily open bank accounts in their name. The process also aims to build donor trust and ensure transparency.

Commission registration services are available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.

The Punjab Home Department has also released details of the registration process.

So far, 68 religious seminaries have completed the sign-up process, while 24 seminaries have submitted all the required information for registration. The Punjab Charity Commission has issued registration certificates to 19 religious seminaries.

As per the directives of the Punjab government, the commission maintains regular contact with religious seminaries across the province. According to official statistics, the commission contacted 2,756 seminaries through telephone calls and a further 1,646 seminaries through SMS messages.

Additionally, 31 meetings and visits were conducted to establish direct contact with religious seminaries and facilitate registration. The Punjab Charity Commission has streamlined and adjusted the registration process to make it easier for religious seminaries to register.

All seminaries operating across Punjab are encouraged to complete their registration online through the Commission portal.

Continue Reading

Business

PSX extends losses as benchmark index sheds over 600 points

Published

on

By

Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) continued its downward trend on Wednesday, with the benchmark KSE-100 index down 627.21 points or 0.35% to 176,890.52.

According to the latest market data, the index hit an intraday high of 177,719.05 points and a low of 176,596.41 points. The trading volume stood at 16.63 million shares.

The benchmark index had closed at 177,517.73 points in the previous trading session, after shedding 665.21 points, or 0.37 per cent, on Tuesday. During Tuesday’s session, the ready market recorded a trading volume of 839.224 million shares as compared to 1,339.586 million shares in the previous session.

The trading volume in the ready market stood at Rs 20.158 billion, up from Rs 32.584 billion recorded a day earlier.

Continue Reading

Trending